MassFiscal calls for suspension of Net Zero mandates, permanent end to costly energy charges, and support for Project Beacon
The Massachusetts Fiscal Alliance today responded to Governor Maura Healey’s declaration of a “state of energy emergency,” saying the Governor’s decision to temporarily remove or reduce state-imposed clean-energy charges is an acknowledgment that Massachusetts’ own energy policies have become part of the state’s affordability crisis.
MassFiscal called for three immediate steps: suspend implementation of the state’s Net Zero mandates, permanently eliminate the energy charges the Governor is temporarily reducing, and support Project Beacon to expand reliable natural gas capacity into Massachusetts.
“Governor Healey is declaring an energy emergency while temporarily reducing charges created by the very energy policies Massachusetts continues to pursue. If these mandates are too expensive for ratepayers during an emergency, policymakers need to ask why they should return when the emergency is over,” said Paul Diego Craney, Executive Director of the Massachusetts Fiscal Alliance. “The SMART charge should not come back in three months, the Alternative Portfolio Standard should not simply return to full strength after the winter, and Massachusetts should stop adding new costs through its Net Zero mandates.”
Healey announced Monday that an executive order will remove the SMART program charge from residential electric bills for three months and cut the Alternative Portfolio Standard charge by 50 percent this winter. She also announced expanded heating assistance but did not provide a total cost for the package during the press conference.
The administration says alternative compliance payments made by electricity suppliers will be used to help cover the relief. But removing a charge from a residential bill does not necessarily eliminate the underlying cost. SMART, APS and similar programs provide subsidies or payments to qualifying energy resources. If those obligations continue, the question is who ultimately pays for them and whether the Governor is eliminating costs or simply shifting them elsewhere.
That question echoes the findings of the Fiscal Alliance Foundation’s November 2025 analysis by energy policy expert Lisa Linowes. The report found that some of the fastest-growing charges on electric bills are tied to renewable mandates, efficiency surcharges and carbon programs created by state law. It specifically warned that administrative action alone cannot solve the problem because the Department of Public Utilities cannot change the statutes responsible for those costs.
“The Governor deserves credit for acknowledging that the policy charges she champions are part of the affordability problem, but temporarily moving a charge off a residential bill is not the same as eliminating the cost,” said Craney. “If ratepayers or taxpayers remain responsible for the underlying subsidies, Massachusetts has only moved the bill around. A declared energy emergency should be an opportunity to confront the policies driving costs in the first place.”
MassFiscal also renewed its call for Healey to support Project Beacon, a proposed expansion that would add approximately 300 million cubic feet per day of natural gas capacity into the region. Research from a Fiscal Alliance Foundation study estimates the additional capacity could save Massachusetts consumers approximately $367 million during an average winter across natural gas and electricity costs.
Healey recently urged federal officials to expedite a separate, significantly smaller expansion of the Algonquin pipeline. Following Monday’s press conference, MassFiscal directly asked the Governor whether she also supports Project Beacon. She declined to answer the question.
“Declaring an energy emergency makes the question surrounding Project Beacon even more urgent,” said Craney. “Massachusetts needs additional reliable energy supply. Governor Healey should make clear whether she supports Project Beacon and, if she does not, explain why.”
MassFiscal called on state policymakers to treat the declared energy emergency as a turning point in Massachusetts energy policy, beginning with permanent relief from costly mandates and a broader effort to repeal Net Zero policies that continue to increase costs for Massachusetts families and businesses.
